Racine County paid $31,828.38 to Milwaukee attorney Samuel Hall to investigate how Sheriff's Office supervisors handled warnings about Deputy Preston Kite.
Hall produced two reports, an internal review dated Dec. 2, 2024, and a follow-up dated Feb. 4, 2025. Neither report has been released to the public.
What has been released is a six-page document written by Sheriff Christopher Schmaling, described in the document itself as a summary of Hall's investigative findings. That summary was filed as a disciplinary complaint against Capt. Cary Madrigal on Feb. 19, 2025.
Madrigal accepted a ten-day suspension without pay and waived a hearing. The complaint cited a policy requiring appropriate action when a supervisor becomes aware of inappropriate behavior, after a deputy reported directly to Madrigal that Kite had sent an explicit photo.
The summary raises questions it does not answer, including what Hall found about other supervisors mentioned in the Sheriff's own introduction, and how long warnings about Kite's conduct toward coworkers had circulated before his arrest.
The 21 members of the Racine County Board hold the privilege the County is claiming over the report and could vote to waive it and release the report with redactions. Supervisors Ernie Rossi and Taylor Wishau have both said they want the full report released.







